Connect with us

Business and Economy

IMF Picks Holes in Nigeria’s budgeting System as Execution Crises Deepen

Published

on

Spread the love

A new International Monetary Fund (IMF) report released yesterday warned that weak budget credibility is undermining macroeconomic stability across sub-Saharan Africa, eroding public trust and weakening long-term development outcomes.

The IMF warning comes on the heels of rising concerns over Nigeria’s persistent cycle of opaque budget administration, spurious benchmark, overlapping execution and revenue shortfalls, challenges that seek to undermine budgeting as a fiscal control tool.

At the federal level, the culture of budgeting as it was known is dying, giving way to unappropriated spending, multiple budget execution, undefined budgeting cycle, among others.

For one, the 2026 appropriation was only signed into law on April 17, over three months into a new fiscal year and over two into its supposed implementation.

A statement by the President’s spokesperson, Bayo Onanuga, shortly after the budget was signed, said the spending guide had taken effect on April 1, raising questions on whether its implementation had commenced before the President’s signature – a necessary aspect of the lawmaking process.

The budget was passed by the two chambers of the National Assembly after the members hurriedly approved the add-on sent by President Bola Tinubu.

At the signing of the appropriation, the National Assembly extended the implementation of the capital component of the 2025 appropriation to June 30, 2026 – a strange fiscal practice invoked recently to manage the public uproar over weak capital budget performance, but which has grown into a budget governance culture.

The decision validated the press’ worries over government’s poor commitment to ending overlapping budget implementation. At the twilight of last year, Tinubu wrote to the parliament requesting the “re-enactment” of a harmonised 2024/2025 appropriation as part of the groundwork to end the history of overlapping budget implementation, which started in 2022 under the late President Muhammadu Buhari.

Since then, budget rollover has become a routine fiscal pathway, though capital expenditure performances have been kneecapped by poor revenue mobilisation to less than 70 per cent. When Tinubu promised the lawmakers an end to multiple budgeting, many analysts, who baulked at his commitment, have been justified by the handling of the 2025 public spending document.

See also  Reps urge PTAD on inclusion of CSR in 2026 Budget

And close to a month after the 2026 budget was signed into law, there is no official confirmation beyond Onanuga’s statement on whether its execution, at least the recurrent component, has commenced.

The IMF report, titled ‘Budget Credibility in Sub-Saharan Africa’, paints a troubling picture of how governments across the region routinely depart from approved fiscal plans, with deficits exceeding projections, current expenditures overshooting limits and capital projects repeatedly abandoned or implementation delayed midway.

The 2024 budget performance was the last of such reports. Then, the government projected a fiscal deficit of N9.17 trillion, which was overrun by N4.34 trillion or 47 per cent. Recent years mirror similar variance in fiscal deficit projection and actual deficit, a crisis fuelled by revenue underperformance or recurrent projection overrun or both.

Many African countries lack commercially viable frameworks that drive public-private partnership (PPP) elsewhere, thus making equity funding a key driver of public infrastructure delivery. With Nigeria’s yearly infrastructure estimated at $300 million by Moody’s in the face of a tattered PPP model, there are not many options for equity infrastructure spending.

The IMF paper studied 39 African countries between 2021 and 2024, with Nigeria featuring prominently in the institutional assessment and exemplifying many of the structural weaknesses highlighted in the report: optimistic revenue assumptions, weak expenditure discipline, fragmented fiscal management systems, poor transparency and recurrent reliance on supplementary or revised budgets that alter the original fiscal framework within months of legislative approval.

The treatment of the 2026 budget speaks expressly about the low attention African countries accord to the transparency canon. Almost a month after the budget was signed, the revised version has yet to be made public, which raises concerns about the government’s commitment to transparency.

The current administration has been accused of failing in fiscal transparency tests. Borrowed funds are spent without clearly articulated justifications. Budget implementation reports (BIRs), which were previously updated quarterly, are now delayed for as much as a year. Close to mid-year, the 2025 full-year BIR is yet to be made public; only the half-year is accessible.

See also  FG reassures of support for Made in Nigeria goods

Recently, the Guardian reported that the FG’s yearly audited financial statement was last transmitted to the National Assembly in 2023, a breach of a provision of the Fiscal Responsibility Act (FRA), a fiscal discipline document that has been abused on all fronts.
For the IMF report, Nigeria, Africa’s once largest economy, is grappling with elevated debt servicing costs, chronic revenue underperformance, ballooning recurrent expenditures, heavy dependence on borrowing, widening infrastructure deficit, as well as rising social spending demand amid a fragile macroeconomic environment.

The exit of Edun
The IMF warned that when governments consistently fail to deliver budgets as approved, fiscal policy loses credibility, investor confidence weakens, and economic uncertainty intensifies.

“Budgets are more than technical documents. They reflect the core policy commitments of a government: setting priorities, allocating scarce resources and signalling the fiscal stance. When these commitments are repeatedly missed, fiscal discipline weakens and macroeconomic uncertainty rises,” the report said.

Fiscal estimates, reality and outlook
The Federal Government’s revised 2026 budget, estimated at N68.32 trillion, was built on crude oil production of 1.84 million barrels per day (mbpd), an oil benchmark price of $75 per barrel and an exchange rate of N1,400/$1, an overshoot of the current dollar-naira exchange value.

Last month, the country’s average production was 1.49mbpd, about 20 per cent short of the target and the highest since the beginning of the year. Shortfalls over the years have been fuelled by pipeline vandalism, oil theft and operational disruptions, divestment by international oil companies (IOC) and poor fresh investment – challenges the government is yet to find solutions to.

Following an upward revision of the budget, Nigeria’s 2026 fiscal deficit is projected at N29.2 trillion, while debt servicing alone is expected to consume over 20 per cent of the entire expenditure.

See also  Tinubu seeks Senate approval for ₦1.15trn loan to fund 2025 Budget

The IMF paper warned that poor budgeting could weaken not only fiscal planning but also governance and accountability structures.

“Credible budgets enable stronger accountability and reinforce the social contract by aligning the government’s stated objectives with its actions,” the report stated.

Nigeria’s recurring budget credibility problems have become more visible over the past decade as fiscal pressures intensified. Large fiscal deficits financed by borrowing, accompanied by weak revenue mobilisation, volatile oil earnings and rising debt service obligations.

Across sub-Saharan Africa, the IMF noted, fiscal deficits consistently exceed approved budget levels because governments tend to overestimate revenues while underestimating spending pressures, a pattern that closely reflects Nigeria’s experience.

Successive Nigerian budgets have repeatedly projected aggressive revenue growth based on overtly optimistic assumptions around crude oil production, exchange rates, tax proceeds and economic growth. Yet actuals often fall below projections.

The IMF found that current expenditures, including wages, transfers and operational spending, consistently exceeded budget ceilings across the region and were the single biggest contributor to fiscal overruns.

The report identified primary current expenditure overruns, rather than interest payments alone, as the major source of budget deviations.

The IMF warned that in many African countries, governments resort to cutting or postponing capital projects whenever revenues disappoint or financing conditions tighten.

The consequences, the report noted, include unfinished roads, delayed infrastructure projects, weak healthcare delivery and underfunded education systems. It warned that this approach ultimately weakens long-term growth and development prospects.

The IMF paper also highlighted how weak expenditure controls and pro-cyclical fiscal behaviour worsen budget credibility problems.

It warned that fragmented cash management systems and weak oversight structures significantly undermine budget credibility across the region.

The report further stressed that weak digitalisation, poor data exchange systems and limited access to timely fiscal information undermine accountability across many African countries.

Business and Economy

FAAC: FG, States, LGs Share N2.4trn in October

Published

on

By

Spread the love

By Son Tertsea, Abuja

The three tiers of government, federal, states and local governments, have shared the Federation Account Allocation Committee (FAAC) sum of N2.441 trillion.

The amount was from the October 2026 Federation Account Revenue, which was shared at the FAAC meeting held in Abuja on Wednesday.

The N2.441 trillion comprised distributable statutory revenue of N1.688 trillion and Value Added Tax (VAT) revenue of N752.488 billion.

A communiqué issued by the Federation Account Allocation Committee (FAAC) indicated that gross revenue of N3.811 trillion was available in the month of October 2026.

Total deduction for cost of collection was N128.797 billion while total transfers, refunds and savings stood at N1.241 trillion.

According to the communiqué sent to media houses by Bawa Mokwa, Director of Press of the Office of the Accountant-General of the Federation, Wednesday night, gross statutory revenue of N2.999 trillion was received for the month of October 2026.

This was lower than the sum of N3.096 trillion received in the preceding month by N97.323 billion.

Gross revenue of N812.446 billion was available from the Value Added Tax (VAT) in October 2026. This was lower than the N816.872 billion available in the month of September 2026 by N4.426 billion.

The communiqué stated that from the N2.441 trillion total distributable revenue, the Federal Government received a total sum of N856.065 billion and the state governments received a total sum of N809.909 billion.

The Local Government Councils received N568.701 billion, while the sum of N206.384 billion (13% of mineral revenue) was shared to the benefiting State as derivation revenue.

See also  BIPC Moves To Stop NEXIM Bank Sale Of Benue Hotels, Alleges Fraud In Lease Deal

On the N1.688 trillion distributable statutory revenue, the Federal Government received N780.816 billion and the State Governments received N396.040 billion.

The Local Government Councils received N305.331 billion and the sum of N206.384 billion (13% of mineral revenue) was shared to the benefiting States as derivation revenue.

From the N752.488 billion distributable Value Added Tax (VAT) revenue, the Federal Government received N75.249 billion, the State Governments received N413.868 billion and the Local Government Councils received N263.371 billion.

In October 2026, Excise Duty and CET Levies increased marginally, while Petroleum Profit Tax (PPT), Hydrocarbon Tax (HT), Petroleum Royalties, Import Duty, Companies Income Tax (CIT), CGT & SDT, Value Added Tax (VTA), Mineral Royalties, and Gas Flared Penalty, Rental Gas Flared Fee and Misc. Oil Revenue all decreased.

Continue Reading

Business and Economy

Dangote Refinery IPO Nets ₦5.85 Trillion From 3.8 Million Investors

Published

on

By

Spread the love

By Seyi Balogun, Lagos

Following the overwhelming response to Dangote Petroleum Refinery’s initial public offering (IPO), attracting share applications worth approximately ₦5.85 trillion from about 3.8 million investors, Nigeria’s capital market has recorded a major investment milestone.

The subscription value is about three times the refinery’s initial fundraising target of ₦2.15 trillion, highlighting the level of interest in the country’s largest private-sector refining investment and the growing appetite for equity participation in major Nigerian businesses.

The offer opened on September 14 and closed on October 27, making 4.1 billion shares available at ₦525 each. However, applications reached approximately 11.15 billion shares, reflecting demand that significantly exceeded the number initially offered.

The figures point to a broad investor base, with retail investors accounting for the largest number of applications. Nearly 3.8 million individual subscribers represented about 84.39 per cent of the investor base, indicating considerable interest among Nigerians in acquiring ownership stakes in the refinery.

Their participation, however, tells a different story when measured by investment value. Retail applications amounted to approximately ₦32.69 billion, representing just 0.56 per cent of the total subscription value.

In contrast, three applicants accounted for approximately 46.72 per cent of the shares requested, with applications valued at about ₦2.73 trillion. The disparity highlights how a relatively small group of major investors can account for a substantial share of capital in large public offers, even when individual investors dominate participation.

International interest also contributed significantly to the subscription figures. Applications from investors outside Nigeria reportedly reached $2.1 billion, while domestic investors accounted for approximately $1.9 billion.

See also  FG reassures of support for Made in Nigeria goods

South Africa’s Public Investment Corporation, which manages pension assets for public-sector workers, was among the international institutions reported to have expressed interest in the offer. Nigerian pension fund managers also indicated interest in acquiring shares.

The offer reportedly attracted investors from 120 countries, including all 54 African nations, extending the refinery’s investment appeal beyond Nigeria’s borders.

The strong subscription response comes as the company advances plans for a $14.3 billion expansion programme over five years. Dangote Refinery intends to increase its refining capacity from approximately 650,000 barrels per day to 1.4 million barrels per day by 2029.

The proposed expansion is expected to strengthen its position in the global petroleum industry while increasing its ability to supply refined products across Nigeria and other African markets.

The public offer forms part of the company’s broader financing strategy for this expansion. Alongside the expected IPO proceeds, the refinery plans to leverage internally generated cash flow and additional financing to support its investment programme.

To accommodate demand beyond the original offer, the Securities and Exchange Commission has reportedly permitted an additional oversubscription of up to 30 per cent, subject to regulatory approval. This could increase the final amount raised beyond the initial target.

However, the ₦5.85 trillion recorded represents applications submitted by investors, not the actual proceeds from the offer. The final amount will depend on the shares allotted following the completion of the regulatory and allocation processes.

As attention shifts to the final allotment and subsequent listing on the Nigerian Exchange, the offering presents an important development for Nigeria’s investment landscape.

See also  Oil Prices Nosedive as U.S. and Iran Reach Deal to Reopen Strait of Hormuz

For the refinery, the scale of investor interest provides an opportunity to broaden its ownership structure and secure additional funding for its expansion ambitions. The next phase will be measured by how effectively it translates that confidence into operational growth, business performance and long-term shareholder value.

Continue Reading

Business and Economy

Refinery IPO Didn’t Hit 10m Investors’ Target: But Shows Investment Habit Changing Fast in Africa — Dangote

Published

on

By

Spread the love

By Seyi Balogun, Lagos

The initial public offering (IPO) of the Dangote Industries Limited (DIL), for the company’s refinery business did not achieve its 10 million investors target, Aliko Dangote, chairman of the group said..

Though falling short of the target, the IPO attracted “millions of investors”, according to Dangote, who revealed this at the 25th annual conference of the Women in Management, Business and Public Service (WIMBIZ) in Lagos.

The billionaire said the number of investors is yet to be officially determined, but attributed the shortfall to the limited time available for the offer and difficulties some prospective investors faced in accessing it.

“We cannot tell the figure right away because we have not reported to this, but we’ve gotten an amazing demand from various people,” Dangote said.

“If you look at it, the largest participating shareholders, like here now, was I think GTBank. When they did their own, it was 200,000. Okay, we are talking about millions of people that participated.

“Even in Kenya, Safaricom was the largest, less than 900,000. Saudi Aramco worldwide was about five million. So, and I’m sure we are not that far away.

“We didn’t hit the 10 million because of time constraint, and a lot of people, they didn’t know how to access.

“But it’s the shared trust of public enterprise that we have today in Africa, and that’s why people are now beginning to remove that money under their mattresses to go and invest.”

See also  House pass bill for early budget submission, Proposes September ending deadline

Tagged ‘The People’s IPO’, the Dangote refinery IPO, offered 4.1 billion shares at N525 each, with a minimum subscription of 10 shares costing N5,250.

The offer opened on September 14 and was extended to October 27.

Dangote had said the company was targeting 10 million retail investors as part of efforts to broaden ownership of the refinery beyond institutional and high-net-worth investors.

Reuters reported that more than two million investors had subscribed through digital channels before the offer closed, while the IPO attracted about N6.4 trillion in orders from Nigerian retail and institutional investors — roughly three times the targeted offer size.

Dangote said subscriptions came from 120 countries, including all 54 African countries.

Asked whether the IPO had changed his view on how Africa could mobilise capital from within the continent, Dangote said, “I think yes, it has actually changed. It has changed things dramatically. Things are really changing very fast”.

Continue Reading

Recent

Education18 hours ago

ABU DSS student wins N1m prize at essay competition

Spread the loveA student of Demonstration Secondary School, Ahmadu Bello University, Adejoh Joshua Unekwu, has clinched a second position at...

General News18 hours ago

Football Legend, Segun Odegbami, Attacked in Abeokuta, Escapes Death

Spread the loveBy Seyi Balogun, Lagos With no clear knowledge of the assailants or their motive, former Super Eagles captain...

General News18 hours ago

FG, Chinese Firm Agree to Produce CNG Buses in Ibadan

Spread the loveBy Seyi Balogun, Lagos To introduce compressed natural gas-powered buses and establish a local assembly plant, to reduce...

Education18 hours ago

JAMB UTME Free for Candidates with Disabilities, Fee Refund at Exam Centres

Spread the loveBy Isa Abdul, Abuja Special examination support has been established for candidates with disabilities, by the Joint Admissions...

General News18 hours ago

Sharing Money is Digging Hole for Eco Woes, Can’t End Poverty – Fasua

Spread the loveBy Son Tertsea, Abuja A warning has been issued that distributing cash to Nigerians without addressing underlying economic...

General News18 hours ago

“I conceded defeat to Buhari, a statesman that loved God, Nigeria.’ –Jonathan

Spread the loveBy Isa Abdul, Abuja The reason for conceding defeat to the late President Muhammadu Buhari in the 2015...

Sports18 hours ago

Secrets Behind Flamingos’ World Cup Win – Busari:

Spread the loveAfter guiding Nigeria’s Flamingos to a historic FIFA U-17 Women’s World Cup triumph, head coach Akeem Busari speaks...

General News2 days ago

Failure to Secure NNPCL GMD Job: EFCC Arraigns Woman Over N1.1 bn Fraud

Spread the loveBy Isa Abdul, Abuja One Halimat Adenike Tejuosho was Wednesday arraigned before a High Court of the Federal...

General News2 days ago

Let’s Honor All Pioneer Paramount Rulers Across Tiv and Idoma Lands.

Spread the loveBy Peters Ichull Today, the Tiv nation and the entire Benue family pause in solemn reflection to mark...

Politics3 days ago

NKST Synod Says: “Alia Is A Talk-And-Do Governor”, Deserves Re-election in 2027

Spread the loveBy Felix Umande The NKST Synod has declared its support for the re-election of Benue State Governor, Rev....